Woman underwater on laptop in Gulf of Mexico near Florida

Top 7 Online Seafood Retailers

In the digital age, the convenience of online shopping has extended to virtually every aspect of our lives, including how we purchase our food. Seafood lovers now have the luxury of accessing a vast array of fresh, high-quality seafood from the comfort of their homes. This article delves into the world of online seafood shopping, highlighting the top 10 retailers that have made a significant mark in 2023. From specialty offerings like gourmet lobsters and artisanal oysters to the broad selections of traditional fish markets, these retailers are redefining seafood accessibility and quality. We’ll explore what makes each of these online stores stand out, ensuring seafood enthusiasts can make informed choices to satisfy their culinary needs.

Criteria for Selection

The selection of the top online seafood retailers is based on a comprehensive set of criteria, ensuring a balanced and fair assessment. Key factors include:

  1. Quality of Seafood: The freshness, taste, and overall quality of the products offered.
  2. Product Range: The variety of seafood available, including specialty items and standard fare.
  3. Sustainability Practices: Commitment to environmentally friendly and sustainable fishing practices.
  4. Customer Service: Responsiveness, helpfulness, and the ability to provide a positive shopping experience.
  5. Pricing: How the cost compares to the quality and range of products offered.
  6. Delivery Options: Efficiency, range of delivery locations, and condition of products upon arrival.

Our List of the Top 7 Online Seafood Retailers

1) Fulton Fish Market

Pros: Wide variety of fresh seafood, high-quality products, good sustainability practices.

Cons: Higher price point, shipping costs can be expensive.

2) Wild Seafood Market

Pros: Highly fresh, locally sourced from Gulf of Mexico seafood. Specializing in Grouper, Snapper and Stone Crab Claws (When in season). Affordable delivery within the state of Florida.

Cons: Limited options as Wild Seafood Market only sells what’s currently in stock. Expensive shipping outside of Florida.

3) ButcherBox Seafood Box

Pros: Offers a subscription service, high-quality sustainable seafood, and convenient delivery.

Cons: Limited selection compared to specialized seafood retailers, subscription model may not suit everyone.

4) Island Creek Oysters

Pros: Specializes in oysters with a reputation for quality and freshness, offers a variety of oyster types.

Cons: Focused mainly on oysters, which might not appeal to those looking for a broader selection.

5) Luke’s Lobster

Pros: Known for sustainably sourced, high-quality lobster, traceability of seafood sources.

Cons: More expensive, primarily focused on lobster and related products.

6) Alaskan Salmon Company

Pros: Specializes in wild-caught Alaskan salmon, known for freshness and quality.

Cons: Limited to salmon, might not suit those seeking a wider range of seafood options.

7) Legal Seafoods

Pros: Long-standing reputation for quality, wide range of seafood products, and restaurant-grade quality.

Cons: Higher prices, may have higher shipping costs depending on location.

Comparative Analysis

When comparing the top seven online seafood retailers several differences and similarities emerge. Fulton Fish Market excels in offering a wide variety of high-quality seafood but at a higher price point. ButcherBox Seafood Box is ideal for those preferring a subscription model, providing convenience though with a more limited selection. Island Creek Oysters and Luke’s Lobster are specialists in their fields, offering unparalleled quality in oysters and lobster, respectively, but their focus is narrow. Alaskan Salmon Company is the go-to for wild-caught salmon but lacks variety. Legal Seafoods stands out for its broad range and restaurant-grade quality, though at a premium cost. Wild Seafood Market, operating from Florida, prides itself on locally sourced, fresh seafood, offering a unique regional selection but may have limited national reach.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Customer feedback for these retailers generally highlights the quality and freshness of the seafood, with particular praise for the niche offerings of Luke’s Lobster and Island Creek Oysters. Fulton Fish Market and Legal Seafoods receive accolades for their wide selection, though some customers note the higher price points. ButcherBox Seafood Box’s subscription service is appreciated for its convenience, but some desire a broader range. Alaskan Salmon Company is consistently praised for the quality of its salmon. Wild Seafood Market, meanwhile, garners positive local reviews for its fresh, Florida-sourced seafood, though it is less known on the national stage. Common criticisms across the board often relate to shipping costs and the occasional delivery delay, typical challenges in the online perishable goods market.


In conclusion, each of these top online seafood retailers offers a unique set of strengths, catering to various preferences and needs. Whether you seek the convenience of a subscription box, the luxury of gourmet lobster, or the specific taste of wild-caught Alaskan salmon, there is a retailer on this list that meets those desires. Wild Seafood Market adds a regional flair with its Florida-based offerings. While prices and selections vary, the common thread is a commitment to quality and freshness, ensuring a delightful seafood experience direct to your door. As the online seafood market continues to evolve, these retailers are poised to lead the way, meeting the demands of seafood enthusiasts with innovation, quality, and a dedication to customer satisfaction.

Bottom line, if you’re located inside the state of Florida, see what Wild Seafood Market has in stock before shopping anywhere else 😉

Share This

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 × four =